Avoid Costly Mistakes. Get Properly Protected.
Most policies look similar — until you have a claim. We help you get the right coverage from the start.
Independent
We work for you
Multiple Carriers
More options
Right Coverage
Not just price
Local People
Local support
What Our Clients Saying
What We Cover
Personal Insurance
Auto, home, renters, umbrella, and more — coverage for individuals and families across Northwest Indiana.
Commercial Insurance
Property, liability, workers' compensation, and more — built for small and mid-sized businesses in Jasper County and Lake County.
Farm Insurance
Coverage for your farm, equipment, crops, and property — from an agency that has served Jasper County agricultural operations since 1953.
Life & Health Insurance
Life insurance and health coverage options compared across multiple carriers — sized to your actual situation, not a default amount.
Why Choose CI Insurance?
We don't sell the cheapest policy.
We help you buy the right one.
Is your insurance actually protecting you or is it just cheap? With access to top-rated insurance companies, we compare options so you get the right coverage at a fair price.
We take the time to understand your needs
Compare multiple carriers for you
Explain your coverage in plain English
Local team you can count on-always
70+
YEARS
In business, proudly serving Northwest Indiana.
10+
LICENSED
AGENTS
Local agents ready to help you.
15+
TOP-RATED COMPANIES
More options. Better coverage.
LOCAL
INDEPENDENT AGENCY
We live and work right here too.
What People Ask Before They Call Us
Who is the best independent insurance agent in Jasper County, Indiana?
Ci Insurance has been voted Best Insurance Agency in Jasper County six times, and Stace Pickering has been voted Jasper County Republican Best Of Jasper County. The agency has served Rensselaer and the surrounding area since 1953.
What is the difference between an independent and captive insurance agent?
A captive agent represents a single insurance company and can only offer that company's products and pricing. An independent agent like Ci Insurance holds contracts with multiple carriers, which means we can compare coverage and price across the market and recommend what actually fits your situation — not just what one company offers.
How do I find a local insurance agency near DeMotte, Indiana?
Ci Insurance operates a local office in DeMotte at 219-987-2151, staffed by agents who live and work in the area. Our Rensselaer and Lowell offices serve the broader Northwest Indiana region. You can also request a coverage review online.
Does Ci Insurance serve clients outside of Jasper County?
Yes. In addition to our primary service area in Jasper County — including Rensselaer, DeMotte, Wheatfield, Remington, Brook, and Roselawn — we serve clients in Lake County, Indiana, including the Lowell area. We are licensed in Indiana, Illinois, and Michigan.
Ci Insurance has been family-owned since 1953 and is now in its third generation. Our staff don't just work in Rensselaer, DeMotte, and Lowell — they live here, coach youth sports here, and volunteer here. When something goes wrong for a client or a neighbor, we show up. That's what makes this agency different from a national brand that has no stake in what happens to your family or your farm.
We're active in Main Street Rensselaer, Little Cousin Jasper, local food banks, and community organizations across Jasper County and Lake County. We've been doing this for over 70 years. Tell us what you have and we'll tell you if it's right.
One Call.
Your Entire Coverage Reviewed.
Not sure if your coverage is doing its job?
Get a free, no-obligation. Coverage Review.
We'll make sure nothing important is missing.
It only takes a few minutes
Northwest Indiana's Independent Insurance Agency — We Work for You, Not the Insurance Company
Most people renew their policy every year without anyone asking whether it still fits. Life changes. Property values change. Your business grows. Your coverage should keep up.
As an independent insurance agency in Rensselaer, Indiana, we compare options across multiple carriers at every renewal — not just roll over what you had last year. If there's a gap in your coverage, we'll tell you. If there's a better fit at a comparable price, we'll show you.
When you have a claim, you need someone in your corner. We advocate for you, not the insurance company — and we've been doing it for three generations.
Family Law
Support through divorce, child custody, alimony, and protective injunctions with compassion and clarity.
Guidance with wills, trusts, and advance directives to protect your family, assets, and long-term peace of mind.
Veterans Disability & Vaccine Injury
Representation for veterans navigating VA disability claims or vaccine injury petitions
Experience, empathy, and dedication to community
Led by attorney Thomas Saxey, a former Los Angeles District Attorney, military JAG officer, and Florida Supreme Court Certified Family Mediator, our firm brings disciplined advocacy and a service-first mindset to every case. Saxey Law pllc stands apart through a combination of professionalism and genuine care, reflecting the values of integrity, precision, and compassion that define our region. We’re not just lawyers in Okaloosa County—we’re part of the community we serve, dedicated to helping our neighbors move forward confidently.
